We Europeans

Europe’s mistaken identities

History suggests that it may even be easier to create an identity for others than to find one for oneself. The ‘Us and Them’ syndrome, where the ‘Them’ are dumped together in a separate communal basket, makes the process a bit easier…

The Greeks called all foreigners barbaros because they couldn’t decipher their babbling. The philosopher Isocrates made things a bit easier by saying that “we consider Greeks those who partake in our culture”. This sense of cultural superiority clearly helped the cultures concerned to lump all their neighbours into a single disparaging basket.

In the early Middle Ages people of the Islamic faith were indiscriminately called Moors. At the receiving end of the Crusades, the Arabs got their own back by calling all westerners Franks.

According to the historian Norman Davis, the inhabitants of the Iberian peninsula also called the Catalans Franks because of their genetic and linguistic links to people further north At the same time, in recognition of a Visigothic kingdom centred on Toulouse, the Catalans referred to the people of southern France as Goths.

Later, the Ottoman Turks responded by indiscriminately calling all inhabitants of the Balkans Greeks, while both sides referred to the good folk manning the fortresses on the borderlands of Transylvania were dubbed Saxons, when many of them came from all over what was to become Germany, as well as Flanders and, to a lesser extent, the Moselle and Wallonia.

The migrants to the Banat and Slavonia, both regions on the banks of the Danube downstream from Belgrade, were labelled Swabians, when they could have come from anywhere in today’s Germany.

From the viewpoint of Westerners, all people east of the Oder were for a long time just called Slavs (a word that mutated to ‘slave’, although some etymologists think it was the other way round).

Rather more mysteriously, throughout Europe, people ranged east of others living further to the west still tend to use words beginning with ‘Wa’ or ‘We’ to describe their generally romanised neighbours: Wallachians (Vlachs from the Slav root Volokh) in the Balkans, Welsch in German for anybody to the southwest, Walliser to describe the inhabitants of the south-western canton of Switzerland (the Valais, to most people) and Waalsch or Walloons in Belgium. Not, however, the Welsh who were anything but romanised: the word used by the English meant ‘aliens’.

There is even a community in the French Vosges mountains speaking a Romance dialect and known as the Welche, i.e. ‘those who do not speak German’.

Maybe all these cases of mistaken identity were, in reality, forgivable. Europe’s history before the emergence of the nation states was essentially one of migration and assimilation, so that fragile ur-identities were easily absorbed and transformed into what came later.

The process of creating a nation often meant running roughshod over individual identities and papering over the ethnic cracks. The inhabitants of Hungary – supposedly as ethnically distinct a body of people as the Finns or, almost, the Basques – are not just Magyars.

Hungary’s citizens include, according to a 1990s study undertaken jointly by a Budapest research institute and a German university, more than one Magyar strain, Armenians, Ruthenians, Croats, Gypsies – and the Swabians again (a splinter group of this ubiquitous race settled in the southern part of the country).

Author :


  1. Pingback: Cialis daily
  2. Pingback: Discount viagra
  3. Pingback: Buy cialis
  4. Pingback: Cialis 20 mg
  5. Pingback: Viagra 5mg
  6. Pingback: Cialis prices
  7. Pingback: writeaessay
  8. Pingback: tedwap.me
  9. Pingback: click here
  10. Pingback: example.org.17
  11. Pingback: site map
  12. Pingback: site Blog Name
  13. Pingback: WOW Site Blog Name
  14. Pingback: xxlhq.top article
  15. Pingback: xxlhq.xyz article
  16. Pingback: xxlph.xyz article
  17. Pingback: xxxpics xyz
  18. Pingback: xxlph xyz
  19. Pingback: pornph xyz
  20. Pingback: xxxph top
  21. Pingback: xxlph.top article
  22. Pingback: xyz
  23. Pingback: adulthq top
  24. Pingback: xxxhd.top article
  25. Pingback: xnxxhd top
  26. Pingback: xxxhq top
  27. Pingback: pornph.xyz article
  28. Pingback: xxlhd xyz
  29. Pingback: adultpics top
  30. Pingback: xxxhq.top article
  31. Pingback: xxxph xyz
  32. Pingback: xnxxhd.top article
  33. Pingback: xxlhd.xyz article
  34. Pingback: pornph.top article
  35. Pingback: xxlhq xyz
  36. Pingback: xxlph top
  37. Pingback: xxxph.top article
  38. Pingback: adultph top
  39. Pingback: xxlhq top
  40. Pingback: adulthd top
  41. Pingback: adulthd xyz
  42. Pingback: pornph top
  43. Pingback: adulthq xyz
  44. Pingback: xxxph.xyz article
  45. Pingback: xxxhd top

Leave a Reply